Is Donald Trump right to claim unfairness over Paris?

There’s a brilliant article from Peter Singer in Project Syndicate this week about Donald Trump’s whinging over the unfairness of the Paris climate agreement. Trump is basically the fat kid who ate 3/4 of the cake and then complained that it’s unfair he didn’t get more while 3 other kids shared the 1/4 remainder between them.

By this standard, was the Paris accord unfair to the US? Hardly. The US currently has less than 5% of the world’s population, but emits nearly 15% of the world’s greenhouse gases. If fairness means that everyone’s slice of pie should be the same size, it is the US that is being unfair, by grabbing a slice that is three times bigger than it should have.

India, by contrast, has 17% of the world’s population and emits less than 6% of its greenhouse gases, so it would be entitled to almost three times its current emissions. Many other developing countries use an even smaller fraction of their per capita share of the atmosphere.

Perhaps equal slices are not the fairest way to divide a pie. One obvious objection is that equal division takes no account of how much the people seeking slices really need them. Are the pie-seekers genuinely hungry, or are they already well fed and just looking for a treat?

But taking need into account does nothing to assist Trump’s case that the US was unfairly treated by the Paris accord, because Americans could easily cut back on luxuries like vacation travel, air conditioning, and meat consumption, whereas less affluent countries need to industrialize to lift their populations out of depths of poverty unknown in the US.

4 thoughts on “Is Donald Trump right to claim unfairness over Paris?

  1. Completely agree with this. The US is one of the worst polluters – and of course it will cost money to clean up – which will hurt profile – and in a capitalist society, that’s never going to go down well.

    1. I don’t think many people realise what’s required and what’s at stake. They think all they need to do is swap the petrol car for an electric car and the problem will be solved.

  2. On behalf of Americans, we apologize. The majority, if people I know at least, did not want to pull out. This is a guy who denies all facts, and has an agenda to piss off the world.

    As someone who does his part to be green, this is extremely upsetting. All Californians are pro Paris Climate agreement.

    1. You don’t have to apologise. It’s not your fault and I think the rest of the world knows that Donald Trump is not speaking for the majority of Americans.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s