Why isn’t Israel Folau selling his possessions to give to the poor?

An Australian football player lost his job with Rugby Australia recently because of comments he made on Instagram. Before I disclose what these comments were, it’s worth pointing out that an employer is free to dismiss employees who break their employment contract provided the contract is legal and I would be surprised if Rugby Australia’s contract wasn’t.

What did he say? He said, “Drunks, homosexuals, adulterers, liars, fornicators, thieves, atheists, idolators … hell awaits you. Repent! Only Jesus saves“.

The ethicist, Peter Singer, has a good opinion piece on the topic in which he supports Folau’s right to freedom of speech – Rugby Australia’s “Own Goal”.

Nevertheless, it cannot be denied that Folau’s post falls squarely within traditional Christian teachings that Christians accepted almost unanimously until the twentieth century, and that continue to be held widely – though against strong and growing opposition – among Christians today. The post clearly draws on Paul’s first letter to the Corinthians, in which Paul is reported as saying: “Or do you not know that wrongdoers will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: Neither the sexually immoral nor idolaters nor adulterers nor men who have sex with men,nor thieves nor the greedy nor drunkards nor slanderers nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God.”

An Australian journalist, David Marr, has a slightly different interpretation – With Israel Folau the church demands a kind of free speech that keeps gays in the firing line.

The fact is, condemning gays to hell is vilification. Yes, St Paul was on the case way back at the start but that only makes it vilification with a pedigree.

While Folau isn’t calling for men like me to be stoned, whipped or pushed off high buildings, I reckon he is free to preach his horrible beliefs. But his freedom shouldn’t trample my freedom or the freedom of anyone else.

We are free to say he’s a dork to carry on like this about gays and drunks and idolaters. (That means Catholics, by the way.) And Land Rover is free to stop him promoting their luxury cars. And GoFundMe is free not to be the platform where he raises millions to fight Rugby Australia.

What’s my view? I certainly don’t share Falou’s beliefs and like Peter Singer, I too am an atheist and have been condemned to hell but since I don’t believe in hell I don’t care. However, I do think that employers can dismiss employees who break their employment contract so I think this is a question of legality and whether he did breach the terms of his contract. According to the legal website, Lexology, Falou is potentially in breach of the player code of conduct which stipulates:

1.3: Treat everyone equally, fairly and with dignity regardless of gender or gender identity, sexual orientation, ethnicity, cultural or religious background, age or disability. Any form of bullying, harassment or discrimination has no place in Rugby.

1.7: Use Social Media appropriately. By all means share your positive experiences of Rugby but do not use Social Media as a means to breach any of the expectations and requirements of you as a player contained in this Code or in any Union, club or competition rules and regulations.

1.8: Do not otherwise act in a way that may adversely affect or reflect on, or bring you, your team, club, Rugby Body or Rugby into disrepute or discredit. If you commit a criminal offence, this is likely to adversely reflect on you and your team, club, Rugby Body and Rugby.

Folau’s contract was worth $4 million per year. He reportedly owns six homes with a combined worth of over $7 million. Folau is a millionaire. And yet he started a GoFundMe page asking for donations for his legal fight against Rugby Australia. When the donations reached $750,000, GoFundMe suspended the page and refunded all the donations because it was against their own terms of service. Following this decision an Australian Christian Lobby group started a new fund-raising campaign for him, kick-starting it with a donation of $100,000.  The last update I saw was this campaign had surpassed $1.8 million in donations.

According to Wikipedia, there are only a handful of passages in the bible that refer to homosexuality and there is some disagreement as to the meaning of these. By contrast, caring for the poor is a fundamental teaching of the Bible and Christians are instructed to sell their possessions so they can give to the poor:

“Sell your possessions and give to the poor. Provide purses for yourselves that will not wear out, a treasure in heaven that will never fail, where no thief comes near and no moth destroys. For where your treasure is, there your heart will be also.”
Luke 12:33-34

According to The World Bank, 10% of the world’s population lives on less than US$1.90 per day (2015 figures). These are people who don’t have sufficient food to eat, housing, or access to clean water. Folau could do much to alleviate this poverty with his $7 million and the $1.8 million he has received in donations. Not only would he be following the teachings of his religion if he did so, but he would also be spreading an admirable message. There is much to be admired about Jesus and his teachings of compassion and forgiveness towards others, even by atheists like me.

little boy carrying can
Photo by Dazzle Jam on Pexels.com

9 thoughts on “Why isn’t Israel Folau selling his possessions to give to the poor?”

  1. Extremely well written and logically processed. I totally agree with your observation and think he should team up with Donald trump. The overriding teaching of ANY faith that is truely worthy of not are those that place emphasis on non judgement of others, equally and respect of all gender diversity and a love of humankind in general. Yes there is freedom of speech and there should be. Legally it was right he as fired. The audacity however that he a ‘christian’ did it in the first place as if it gives him the right to do so is wrong and secondly to crowdfund, given his financial status. He hasn’t a Christian bone in his body. .. I’m also an aethist. Be kind to others, do not judge others , compassion, empathy and self reflection with reap far greater rewards.

  2. Agree on all counts… this was extremely well written and engaging. Being non judgmental , compassionate with empathy is far more rewarding in many ways even financially which is quite ironic given the situation. Had he not been so scathing and such a shallow India he wouldn’t have lost his job or the subsidy funding.. I also agree that freedom of speech should continue otherwise there will be no democratic process in thought, action or words. However he is self righteous, has no dignity /respect for himself or others . No one has the right to say they are any better than anyone else .. it saddens me to think that there a many people like him who are in a prominent social position who could use their status for good rather than for divisiveness. I too am an atheist yet far more’christian’ than he.

    1. Thanks, Mazza. I totally agree. I think your comment got posted twice but they’re both a bit different so I’ll leave the two here 🙂

      It’s so true that he’s in a prominent position in society and could be using that position to do some real good rather than hounding an already vulnerable group of society.

  3. Whenever I see stories like this, I can’t help feeling that people with religious faith always want to have their cake and eat it. They cherry-pick passages from their holy books, and twist them to fit their agenda. They also cite chapter and verse without thinking objectively. Take this case for example – if you throw condemnation around, is that not hate speech? is it not judging others ? What happened to free will ? It’s all SO hypocritical.

    1. Yes, I agree. Some people would regard telling a person they’re going to hell as hate speech. It’s a tricky one though. At the very least it’s inflammatory and I can see why an employer wouldn’t want their employees saying this on social media.

  4. I like Peter Singer as well, but I feel like the right of free speech is often abused these days, especially since the rise of certain politicians with a nationalist/hateful agenda. In a liberal democracy, everyone is entitled to one’s opinion: but to go up to a person who is, for instance, gay, and tell him he’s going to hell because of who he is—I think that’s bullying on the personal level, and if done at the workplace, it’s an attempt at pushing them out of a job. As for asserting that “the Bible says” as justification for your beliefs, a lot of those passages are not anything Jesus himself said; they are interpretations by followers of Christianity after Jesus’ death, or are from the Old Testament, which also suggests we stone our adult children to death for disobeying their parents, or that a person may be executed for worshiping false idols, swearing or practicing magic. We don’t observe such nonsense now for obvious reasons; but if we did, there would be many a Christian who would be buried under a pile of stones now. Also, it’s on point that a really observant Christian should give away his wealth to help the poor. When a man of obvious means came up to Jesus and asked to become his disciple, Jesus told him to first give away all his money, lands and goods. The man, upset, walks away, whereupon Jesus says the now ubiquitous “It is easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than a rich man enter the kingdom of God.” Though I don’t think Folau has thought it out quite that far.

    1. That is a great quote about the camel. I had heard that before but had forgotten. And yes, telling someone they’re going to hell because of who they are could easily be construed as bullying.

  5. Thank you very much for this incredibly interesting and insightful article! I really appreciated your perspective and agree with what you have stated. I have recently published an article on my bog about what I think we can learn from the Israel Folau saga over the past 8 months. If you have time, It would be great if you could check out my post as I would be really interested to hear your thoughts! Thanks 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s