Photo of my allotment with Hoss the cargo bike in the foreground.

What happened to the Green party?

A Green party candidate won a seat in the Leeds city council elections yesterday and he and his supporters celebrated by unfurling a Palestinian flag and shouting, “Allahu Akbar”.

I was curious to see what green policies he actually held because surely a Green party candidate would be championing segregated bike paths, low emission zones, protection for our wildlife, advocating a plant-based diet, and increasing biodiversity. But no, aside from a photo of him tending what looks like an allotment, green policies there are none.

What happened to the Green party? I used to think my views aligned most closely with them but for several years now I’ve felt that’s no longer the case as the party has got tangled in identity politics, stifling of free speech, and now it seems, foreign wars. I don’t think my views have changed greatly. It’s they who have changed. I will definitely never vote for a party that openly supports terrorists either.

Mothin Ali has deleted his Twitter account now whether because someone advised him this was not a good look or maybe he realised himself but not before someone took a screenshot of his Tweet on October 7th when Hamas invaded Israel – because let’s never forget who started this war.

Since the Tweet no longer exists I wanted to confirm he really did say that and it was not doctored so I searched Google and it still comes up in Google’s results, at least for now so I took a screenshot myself.

I’m not the only person to be concerned with the left’s abandonment of free speech. Peter Singer is quoted in the Australian Financial Review this week – Left has abandoned free speech: Singer

“What used to be things that were generally accepted by people on the progressive side of politics have shifted – and freedom of speech is a basic example”

On the occupation of universities by pro-Palestinian protestors he says it’s completely reasonable for universities to remove the protestors saying,

“I think they’re [universities] against things that are clearly illegal, that are trespass and causing harassment and abuse of university faculty and staff.

“The students who are pro-Palestine are perfectly free to speak, but they’re not free to occupy buildings.”

We have religious freedom in this country and our politicians are free to follow and practice any religion they desire. But I take exception to faith-based leadership which is when religion becomes a basis for policy. Decisions made by governments should be based on evidence, not religious belief because not everyone is religious and those who are religious follow different religions. You cannot lead a diverse population and make sound policy decisions for that population if your policy comes from your personal religious belief because it won’t speak to the population who don’t share that belief. If however, policy is based on sound evidence and can be argued with reason and logic then it is policy for everyone. I think we should all be concerned when politicians start chanting, “Allahu Akbar”.

And finally, it just seems a bit odd to me for someone to win an election in Britain and then raise a flag for another country at the election victory party. If I were to stand in a local election then raise a flag for New Zealand or Australia, I would hope a few eyebrows would shoot up because I’m not living in either of those countries. I’m living in the UK and a politician, especially a local council politician, should be advocating for local issues.

To end, I’ll share a photo I took on Friday of my allotment, which I cycled on my cargo bike to, and that I use no pesticides or poisons on and where I’m careful to use netting that won’t tangle and kill the local wildlife. Does this make me more of a greeny that Mr Ali?

Comments

7 responses to “What happened to the Green party?”

  1. Katrina Avatar

    It’s my opinion that the Green parties everywhere have been seen as an ‘easy in’ for those who wouldn’t be acceptable to other political parties. Their standards for candidates, in the name of DEI, have probably become lower than other parties’ standards in their haste to be progressively correct.

    I was listening to a Triggernometry podcast recently, and they played a Matt Walsh clip – and I know Matt Walsh is a dick in many ways – but he was talking about evidence he’s obtained which showed that since DEI was incorporated into the recruitment of air traffic controllers in the USA, the incidences of aircraft near misses whilst in flight had increased to almost double. It’s becoming more evident that recruiting on the basis on DEI instead of meritocracy, for fear that it might create a too-white workforce in the West, has meant lowering standards almost everywhere.

    1. Rachel M Avatar

      Yes after reading about this I wondered how it works. Can anyone join a political party and stand as a candidate? Doesn’t the party need to do some vetting to make sure they’re not allowing criminals to stand?

      And I agree on the DEI policies. It should be based on merit and hard work in my view.

  2. Katrina Avatar

    I think all political parties do a certain amount of vetting, but I would hazard a guess that anyone who is under the DEI umbrella are vetted less rigorously.

  3. Denise Avatar

    Maybe also you need a strong will of the leadership to keep MP behaviour in line. I think Keir Starmer’s work to root out anti-Semitism in the Labour party has been ignored, when he has done something very important. It’s not necessarily a vote winner to stop people from behaving badly, so maybe parties just don’t bother unless they have a strong moral imperative from the top.

    1. Rachel M Avatar

      Yes, I didn’t really understand anti-semitism before October 7th. Now I do and can better understand Keir Starmer’s position and am pleased he’s made an effort to deal with it in the Labour party.

  4. russellseitz Avatar
    russellseitz

    Muslim attraction to the Green Party may be in part reflexive- the flags of Pakistan and Saudi Arabia are themselves reflections of the Green Banner of Islam:

    https://aboutislam.net/muslim-issues/science-muslim-issues/raising-green-banner-islam/

    1. Rachel M Avatar

      Interesting. I didn’t realise they specifically aligned with the Green environmental policies. I assumed like Katrina in the comments above that the Green party was just an easy one to join without sufficient vetting. Perhaps it’s a bit of both.

Leave a comment